Court tosses out short-sellers’ lawsuit targeting Overstock’s 'digital dividend'

The lawsuit, accusing Overstock of market manipulation through its security token airdrop, has been turfed by a federal judge.

A Utah federal judge has tossed out a lawsuit that accused Overstock ($OSTK) of market manipulation by distributing a ‘digital dividend’ of security tokens to shareholders and repeatedly revising retail earnings guidance upward to punish short-sellers.

U.S. district judge Dale Kimball granted two motions to dismiss the suit on September 28, finding that the digital dividend did not manipulate the market, and that the revised earnings statements were protected by the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act. In his judgement Kimball said:

“On the day that Overstock announced the dividend, market observers recognized and publicized that the digital dividend would place short sellers in a pickle by forcing them to cover their short positions to avoid breaching pre-existing contractual obligations.”

The lawsuit was filed by Mangrove Partners Master Fund in September 2019, two months after Overstock, a former-online retailer-turned crypto retailer, announced its digital dividend. The dividend airdropped ‘OSTKO’ security tokens to Overstock shareholders at a ratio of one token for every ten shares.

Mangrove claimed that conditions that prohibited the token’s sale until six months after distribution were intended to make it hard for shorters to cover their positions, and accused Overstock of engineering an artificial short squeeze.

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission later launched an investigation into the actions of Overstock and its executives, subpoenaing documents concerning the dividend, in addition to communications with the firm’s former CEO Patrick Byrne.

Judge Kimball ruled that Byrne’s “very public disdain” for shorters (he made numerous disparaging comments about them) was not relevant to the case as “there was a legitimate business purpose for issuing the dividend.”

He summed up the lawsuit as “a classic attempt to plead fraud by hindsight.”

Speaking to Law360, Byrne’s attorney Robert Driscoll said: “Federal securities laws do not serve as investment insurance and the court agreed.”

from https://ift.tt/348zkEp
https://ift.tt/3lbz1jd

Comments

ENS DAO delegates offer perspective on DAO governance and decentralized identity

AlphaWallet CEO and Spruce co-founder talk about their roles as contributors to the Ethereum Name Service following the project's recent airdrop. Earlier this month, the Ethereum Name Service, or ENS, formed a decentralized autonomous organization, or DAO, for the ENS community. Cointelegraph spoke to two ENS DAO delegates who applied for the opportunity to represent the community and stay involved in the decision making process: Victor Zhang, CEO of AlphaWallet, an open source Ethereum wallet, and Gregory Rocco, co-founder of Spruce, a decentralized ID and data toolkit for developers. Zhang spoke about his experience as an external contributor to ENS and an early supporter since 2018. Zhang initially sought to help ENS by offering Alpha Wallet as a user-friendly tool for resolving .eth names and cryptocurrency wallet addresses. Essentially, if a user inputs an .eth name in the AlphaWallet, it will show the wallet address, and vice versa using reverse resolution. Alpha...

How Social Platform Chingari is Using Web 3.0 to Transform the Traditional Way We Use Social Media

The world is changing. This isn’t news to anyone, but sometimes it is nice to realize that—contrary to news headlines—not all the change is bad. In fact, the last decade has seen so much innovation and so many improvements to technology that even 2015 seems like a different world. Internet speeds, connecting with anyone globally (for free), and our ability to reach large groups of people without a middleman is nothing short of revolutionary. When it comes to technology evolution, this often happens with different iterations. Once a system is mature, there’s a better idea of what we would like to change and improve. We go back to the drawing board, target our creative minds at the issues, and create a new version that has evolved to better meet our needs. The Internet has followed this model since its inception, evolving through three distinct stages. We are only at the cusp of the third stage, called Web 3.0, with technologies such as blockchain and ...

Osprey sues Grayscale for misrepresenting likelihood of GBTC ETF approval

Osprey alleges its only competitor on the BTC OTC trust asset market gained its 99.5% market share by misrepresenting the likelihood of its trust becoming an ETF. Digital asset manager Osprey Funds filed suit against Grayscale Investments in Connecticut Superior Court on Jan. 30, alleging violation of the state’s Unfair Trade Practices Act. The suit concerns Grayscale advertising and promotion of the Bitcoin ( BTC ) exchange-traded fund (ETF) it is seeking to create. Osprey stated in the suit that it is the only competitor to Grayscale on the over-the-counter traded Bitcoin trust asset management market, and Grayscale maintained its leading position through deceit: “Only because of its false and misleading advertising and promotion has Grayscale been able to maintain to date approximately 99.5% market share in a two-participant market despite charging more than four times the asset management fee that Osprey charges for its services.” Specifically, Osprey alleged that Graysc...

Crypto Coin Search

Search This Blog